- CO2
- R744
- Pressure equipment
Transcritical CO2 (R744): what high pressures change
With R744, high pressures cross the PS x V thresholds sooner. Coverage, equipment list, relief valves: the practical impact on pressure equipment monitoring.
By cDESP team6 min read
CO2 is not like other refrigerants
Carbon dioxide (R744) has become established in food retail and cold storage. For the monitoring of pressure equipment (ESP, équipements sous pression), it has a feature that changes a lot: it operates at much higher pressures than conventional fluorinated refrigerants.
The reason lies in its physical properties. According to NIST data, its critical point is at about 31 °C and 73.8 bar (absolute pressure), and its triple point at about -56.6 °C and 5.2 bar (absolute). Two practical consequences:
- above about 31 °C, CO2 no longer condenses: on the high-pressure side, the installation runs in transcritical mode with a gas cooler instead of a condenser, at high pressures;
- below about 5.2 bar absolute, liquid CO2 cannot exist: a sudden expansion can form dry ice, which matters for relief valve discharge piping.
The PS values of an installation depend on its design. Only the nameplate and the instructions of each item of equipment are authoritative.
More pressure, more equipment in scope
The thresholds for in-service monitoring are based on the product PS x V for vessels and on DN and PS x DN for piping (article R. 557-14-1 of the code de l'environnement, the French Environmental Code). CO2 is generally a group 2 fluid within the meaning of article 13 of Directive 2014/68/EU (the Pressure Equipment Directive, PED), because it does not have the CLP hazard classes that would place it in group 1. Always check this in section 2 of your supplier's safety data sheet.
For a vessel containing a group 2 gas, in-service monitoring applies in particular when PS x V exceeds 200 bar.L and PS exceeds 4 bar. With high PS values, this threshold is reached by very small volumes. Fictitious examples, to illustrate the order of magnitude:
| Equipment (example) | PS | V | PS x V | Above 200 bar.L? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oil separator | 120 bar | 5 L | 600 bar.L | Yes |
| Suction accumulator | 45 bar | 8 L | 360 bar.L | Yes |
| Liquid receiver | 90 bar | 120 L | 10,800 bar.L | Yes |
On an R404A or R134a installation of comparable capacity, several of these small vessels would be below the thresholds. With CO2, List 6-III often gets longer, and that is normal.
The commissioning declaration may come into play
Article 7 of the arrêté du 20 novembre 2017 (French ministerial order of 20 November 2017 on in-service monitoring of pressure equipment) makes gas vessels whose PS exceeds 4 bar and whose PS x V product exceeds 10,000 bar.L subject to a commissioning declaration and a commissioning inspection. With CO2, a liquid receiver of ordinary size can cross this threshold, like the third example in the table. In that case:
- the declaration is filed by the operator before first commissioning, via the LUNE online service (articles 8 and 9);
- the commissioning inspection is carried out before commissioning, as a general rule by a competent person (personne compétente), and gives rise to a certificate (articles 10 and 11);
- the proof of filing goes into the operating file (article 6).
Do the calculation for each vessel from the design stage, with the manufacturer's actual PS and volumes.
Several pressure levels in the same system
A transcritical CO2 rack often has several stages: high pressure at the compressor outlet and gas cooler, intermediate pressure at the receiver, medium- and low-temperature suction. Each part has its own PS.
For the equipment list, this means a simple rule: one row per item of equipment, with its own PS. A "system" PS copied onto every item distorts the PS x V calculation, and therefore whether the equipment is covered and how it is classified. Also state the pressure level (HP, intermediate, MT, LT) in a dedicated column: the inspector and the technician will find their way around faster.
Standstill pressure: a design issue that affects monitoring
Above the critical temperature, the CO2 contained in an installation at standstill can no longer remain in liquid-vapour equilibrium. The pressure rises with the ambient temperature. Installations protect themselves against this in different ways depending on their design: standby cooling unit, receiver PS sized accordingly, controlled venting.
For in-service monitoring, remember two points:
- relief valves may be called upon during a prolonged standstill, for example a power cut in summer. A relief valve opening is an event to be recorded in the log (article 6 of the order);
- if pressure holding relies on an auxiliary unit, its proper operation is part of the safety of the installation. The inspection plan and the manufacturer's instructions specify what must be checked.
Relief valves and discharge piping: points of attention specific to CO2
The order requires safety accessories to be sized according to the operating conditions, to be set at most at PS, and the discharge of fluid to present no danger (article 3). With CO2, this translates into a few points to watch:
- there are several set pressures: one relief valve per pressure level, to be checked one by one against the PS of the protected equipment;
- the risk of dry ice in discharge piping, linked to the triple point, must be taken into account in their design;
- the discharge must be directed to a safe area: CO2 is heavier than air and can accumulate in low-lying rooms;
- replacements of relief valves (model, set pressure, connection) are recorded in the file and may call the calculation note into question.
Sizing falls under standard NF EN ISO 24664, which we present in our article on the relief valve calculation note.
What does not change
The framework remains the same as for other refrigerants: the arrêté du 20 novembre 2017, and for the installations that apply it, the professional technical code (CTP, cahier technique professionnel) "Systèmes frigorifiques sous pression" (pressurised refrigeration systems), in its version of 8 April 2026 approved by BSERR decision No. 2026-002 (BSERR: Bureau de la sécurité des équipements à risques et des réseaux, a ministry office). The intervals and content of inspections and requalifications follow from these texts and from the inspection plan: check the CTP provisions that concern your equipment, and have special cases confirmed by your authorised inspection body (organisme habilité).
Checklist for a CO2 installation
- One row per item of equipment in the list, with its own PS and pressure level
- PS x V calculated for each vessel, including small volumes
- Vessels above 10,000 bar.L identified, commissioning declaration and inspection certificate filed
- Each relief valve identified, with its set pressure and the protected equipment
- Calculation note for relief valves and discharge piping up to date
- Standstill pressure holding checked according to the instructions
- Relief valve openings recorded in the log
With cDESP
For each item of equipment entered, cDESP suggests a category and indicates whether it requires a commissioning declaration, based on the fluid group, PS and the volume or DN: an aid to sorting, to be checked against the manufacturer's documents. The free tool VerifDESP also gives a first opinion based on PS and V. The calculation note module for relief valves and discharge piping, under NF EN ISO 24664, structures the data for each branch of the installation.
To monitor a CO2 installation item by item, create an account or see the pricing.