- Relief valves
- NF EN ISO 24664
- Calculation note
Relief valve calculation note: NF EN ISO 24664 explained
Required flow, valve capacity, inlet and outlet pressure losses: understand and review an NF EN ISO 24664 calculation note without being an engineer.
By cDESP team6 min read
Why a calculation note for a relief valve
A safety valve is the last line of defence for pressure equipment. It still has to be able to discharge enough fluid, fast enough, for the pressure not to exceed what the equipment can withstand. That is what a calculation note demonstrates.
The regulations set the framework without giving a method. The arrêté du 20 novembre 2017 (French ministerial order of 20 November 2017 on in-service monitoring of pressure equipment) provides, in its article 3:
- that equipment exposed to a risk of exceeding its pressure limits is fitted with a safety accessory set at most at the maximum allowable pressure PS;
- that a short-term excess is allowed while the accessory operates, the momentary overpressure being limited to 10% of PS;
- that safety accessories are sized according to the operating conditions, and that the discharge of fluid presents no danger.
Directive 2014/68/EU (the Pressure Equipment Directive, PED), for its part, requires (Annex I, point 2.11) that pressure limiting devices prevent the pressure from permanently exceeding PS.
The method, however, comes from standardisation. For refrigerating systems and heat pumps, the reference today is ISO 24664:2024, adopted in Europe as EN ISO 24664:2024 and published in France as NF EN ISO 24664. It succeeds EN 13136, which is still cited in older notes.
What the standard covers
According to its scope, the standard deals with three families of calculations:
- the mass flow to be discharged to size the pressure relief devices of a part of the refrigerating system;
- the discharge capacity of relief valves and other devices, including when they discharge to atmosphere or to a lower-pressure part of the system;
- the pressure losses in the inlet (upstream) and outlet (downstream) piping of these devices.
It also specifies how to choose devices to protect against sources of overpressure: internal and external heat input (including exposure to an external fire), sources that raise the pressure such as compressors or heaters, and thermal expansion of trapped liquid.
The standard is not free and its formulas cannot be reproduced here. The aim of this article is to help you understand the logic of a note and know how to review it.
The logic in four questions
For each relief valve, a calculation note answers four successive questions.
1. How much must be discharged?
This is the required flow. It depends on the source of overpressure considered: an external fire around a receiver depends on the external surface area of the equipment, a compressor that keeps discharging against a closed valve depends on its flow. The note must say which sources were taken into account, and why the others were ruled out.
2. How much can the relief valve discharge?
This is the discharge capacity, calculated from the valve's flow area, its discharge coefficient certified by the manufacturer, the fluid and the relieving pressure. The capacity must be at least equal to the required flow.
3. Does the inlet piping restrict too much?
Between the equipment and the relief valve, the piping, the nozzle and any changeover valve create an inlet pressure loss. If it is too high, it can make the valve operate unstably. The note compares this loss with the allowable limit.
4. Does the outlet piping hinder opening?
After the relief valve, the discharge piping and any common header create a back pressure. If it is too high, it reduces the valve's capacity or disrupts its operation. The note checks the outlet pressure loss, taking into account the other relief valves connected to the same header.
If any one of these four answers is negative, protection is not demonstrated, even if the other three are fine.
The data to gather
| Data | Where to find it |
|---|---|
| Refrigerant | Installation nameplate, refrigerant log |
| PS and volume of each protected item of equipment | Nameplate, instructions, declaration of conformity |
| External dimensions (for external heat input) | Manufacturer's drawing or data sheet |
| Compressors that can discharge into the equipment | Refrigeration diagram, compressor data sheets |
| Relief valve model, set pressure, flow area, discharge coefficient | Data sheet and certificate from the valve manufacturer |
| Inlet piping: diameter, length, elbows, connection | Site survey, isometric drawing |
| Any changeover valve and its characteristics | Manufacturer's data sheet |
| Outlet piping and header: diameters, lengths, fittings | Site survey, isometric drawing |
| Discharge point | Site survey |
Site surveys are often the weak link. A note calculated on the original drawing is worthless if the discharge piping was extended during works.
Reading a note without being an engineer
A well-made note can be reviewed in a few minutes with the right questions:
- Can the installation be identified? Site, installation, tags of the equipment and relief valves identical to those on the list and in the field.
- Are the assumptions written down? Fluid, overpressure sources considered, pressures taken into account, reference and edition of the standard.
- Are the input data sourced? Each relief valve coefficient must come from a manufacturer's document.
- Does each relief valve have its four checks? Required flow, capacity, inlet loss, outlet loss.
- Does the diagram match the field? A wrong topology (forgotten header, missing branch) invalidates the calculation.
- Is the note dated and signed? With the name of the person who drew it up.
The most common mistakes
The relief valve replaced by another model. Same set pressure, same connection, but a different flow area or coefficient: the note is no longer valid. Any replacement of a safety accessory must be recorded in the operating file (dossier d'exploitation), which contains the identification of the safety accessories and their setting parameters (article 6 of the order).
The set pressure above PS. The order requires a setting at most at PS. Check valve by valve, especially when equipment with different PS values shares the same protection.
The common header ignored. Each relief valve is calculated on its own, whereas they discharge together into the same header: the actual back pressure is underestimated.
Trapped liquid forgotten. A section of piping full of liquid between two closed valves can rise in pressure as it warms up. The standard covers this case, the note must say how it was examined.
CO2 and dry ice. With R744, expansion in the discharge piping can form dry ice. See our article on transcritical CO2.
Who draws up the note, and when to review it
The standard describes calculation methods, it does not designate a signatory. In practice, the note is drawn up by the designer, the installer or an engineering firm, then filed in the operating file. Safety accessories are examined during periodic inspections and requalifications (articles 19 and 22 of the order), and the authorised inspection body (organisme habilité) may ask to see the justification of their sizing.
Review the note at every change that affects one of the four points: relief valve replacement, piping modification, addition of a compressor, change of refrigerant, addition of equipment on a header.
With cDESP
cDESP includes a calculation note module for relief valves and discharge piping under NF EN ISO 24664. It guides data entry installation by installation (protected equipment, relief valves, inlet and outlet piping, headers), draws the topology diagram and produces a PDF that records the assumptions and the source of each piece of data. The module structures and documents the calculation: review and validation remain the job of a qualified person, with support from DCRR experts if needed.
To discover the module, create an account or see the pricing.